TheStorm said:
Packchem91 said:
910wolf said:
jkpackfan said:
Packchem91 said:
910wolf said:
Really fun thought exercise here. It's so hard to win majors in this era because there are so many capable players. Don't see anyone on the list getting past 5.
I agree on the depth of talented players. But I could see Rahm getting the most
And if Rory ever gets straight, he would (but we've been saying that a long time now)
I say either Rahm or Scheffler, both are on another level at the moment. I know Scheffler didn't have his best tournament but that dude seems to always be in the top 10-15 of every tournament, same with Rahm.
That's the easy thing to say right now, but you never know how long these runs will last.
At the end of 2014 you would have thought Rory would have way more than 4 by now.
At the end of 2017 you would have thought Spieth would have more than 3 by now.
At the end of 2019 you would have thought Koepka would have more than 4 by now.
There's just so many dudes that can win.
Great point. Golf success at highest level is fleeting for everyone not named Tiger / Jack
Throw in Jason Day and JT - for both, not that long ago, they looked like multiple major win guys.
It's nice to see Day playing well, but JT has been average the last couple of years
And JT just won a major last year… but overall, I agree.
I think Speith could get to 5, but honestly these days he's either on - or completely off…
Scheffler is tempting, but majors are just so hard to win, and are spaced out just enough where it is hard to take advantage of getting on a roll…
So, I'd have to either go Rahm or Morikawa here… I think Rahm can play anywhere, and Collin is just so good on the traditional US Open / PGA type layouts… and they are probably the two youngest with two under their belts already.
Majors being hard to win? Even Phil - as great a career as he has had - only has 6… and a couple that were totally unexpected and out of nowhere in the big picture (last 2).
Majors winners the last 5 years plus 2023
Reed, Koepka, Koepka, Molinari
Woods, Koepka, Woodland, Lowry
DJ, Morikawa, Dechambeau
Matsuyama, Mickelson, Rahm, Morikawa
Scheffler, JT, Fitzpatrick, Smith
Several young guns, two legends who were surprises, a couple of outliers (Lowry, Molinari). A guy who took the tour by storm but has since fallen apart in Dechambeau.
A guy who almost never wins, until there is a major in Koepka
And while I still think Rahm and Scheffler are odds on to win another this year, you even have some resurgent old heads like Day and Rose who did well enough at Augusta to make you think they could contend this year.
Lots and lots of good players these days
And all of this debate still makes Tigers winning %, his making cut streaks and his majors wins amongst the most impressive sporting accomplishments of our life time. Dude was clearly hurt and still went out there and beat a lot of the guys on this list this past week after not playing for months