Ripper said:I've seen zero valid evidence that masks make "a difference". If you have real world evidence, please share. I can be persuaded by actual real world controlled studies that show positive efficacy, even partial positive efficacy. And please do not include pseudo lab studies using large aerosols or anything showing correlation. We are 18 months into this virus and mask mandates. There must be some real world evidence somewhere that masks work on the actual Covid-19 virus.Mormad said:Ripper said:(Conversely) Unfortunately many thousands and thousands of masked individuals got Covid-19, so your anecdotal "superhuman" explanation does not hold water. It would have been super easy for a Government medical body to do a serious valid controlled study to measure the efficacy of the flimsy masks against Covid-19, but they have not done so. Or maybe they have and didn't like the results?Mormad said:Wayland said:Or the real world level of masking and masks used are not an effective prophylactic measure for an aerosolized virus. They lead to people who should actually be acting with extra caution to take undue risk due to their belief that a dirty rag on over their mouth will prevent disease. If COVID was only respiratory droplet spread, then maybe... but we should be well past that myth.Mormad said:Civilized said:caryking said:That was good Civ... I love how you project your feelings and/or thoughts on others. Not intrusive, no emotional cost... that's rich, civ!Civilized said:caryking said:Hey... Civ is actually espousing a conservative idea... also, do you feel the same about mask?Civilized said:Packchem91 said:
New York City will require vaccines for entry to restaurants and gyms - CNN
I don't think its the government's place to dictate this for private businesses. But not a surprise it would be NYC.
Agree 100%.
THIS is a freedom being taken from Americans/business owners.
No.
Masks are essentially no risk and are not intrusive.
Also, very importantly, they don't have consequential economic or emotional associated costs. They don't create isolation. They don't keep anyone from making a living.
They're all upside.
How are masks intrusive or emotionally costly, especially compared to any other mitigating behavior including vaccines or shutdowns?
I don't think they are in the true sense of those words, but i can see how some are just sick of them, especially those who believe they don't make a difference, who are angry because they feel somebody is making them do something they don't want to do, or who feel they're symbols of virtue signaling.
I'm sick of masking, and I'm probably the biggest pro-mask guy here. I can wear a mask all day in the OR and not think twice about it, but wearing one in the office or around the hospital makes me feel like I'm suffocating.
Others here disagree, but i do it because i believe that, other than vaccines and avoidance of human interaction, a mask is the best we can do to protect ourselves during day to day interactions.
And they enable the fringe crazies to believe they will never get a respiratory virus again and if they do it is the fault of the unclean and unwashed unbelievers.
Now, again, if we are going full on fitted sterile high level masks, we can talk. But come on... masking is a joke at this point. Take a 30 second watch at the Olympics. Mask on on podium, mask off as we wrestle around with each other, mask partially on as we walk around, mask on one ear as we talk, masks off again for a selfie.
The level of care, caution, quality needed for masks to be real world effective is outlandish.
Use them in with ACTUAL FOCUS where they can have real incremental benefit.
Believe what you want and say what you will. I have a little real world experience with masks. i and my peers had frequent interactions with veritable shtloads of patients, many of whom we found out were positive AFTER said interactions, and interviewed and examined them with nothing more than a mask. And very few wore N95s except in specific situations. As I've said here before, I too have read the "evidence" people who think masks are a joke like to site, but i work every single day with hundreds of peers making thousands of human interactions (before vaccines) and protected by nothing except a mask and hand soap, and very few got it. That's a lot of real world evidence that masks make a difference when used correctly, even when not high level sterile masks in the face of an aerosolized virus. I changed my dirty mask about once a week. I wore an N95 less than 10 times. So I'm not sure the undue risk theory flies. Fringe crazies? They're everywhere and making silly choices no matter the factor... Masks are but one factor. That's not changing and not worth altering beliefs over. And, yes, i laugh at examples of politicians and athletes and other examples of stupid mask use too.
And since it's so aerosolized, it's floating around our hospitals and offices like a fart. So we're constantly exposed i guess. Maybe we're just superhuman. Or maybe, just maybe, masks make a difference.
The joke is in human behavior and policy making, not the utility of a mask.
How do you know if they were masked and when they got it? Also, i have said here before, they're not impenetrable iron curtains. But to suggest they make no difference is also just plain wrong.
Well, there's a difference between real world evidence and real world controlled studies. I have offered my real world evidence above. Thousands of doctors managing eleventybillion patients and a low transmission rate. Real world controlled studies are more difficult because you have to find a cohort willing to be in the unprotected exposure line. It's akin to asking men to sleep with HIV positives with and without protection to prove condoms offer some relative reduction in transmission. It's just hard to construct that study. It would be great though.