Oldsouljer said:Civilized said:Oldsouljer said:Civilized said:
Well said, Rand.We don’t blow up boats off Miami because 25% of the time suspicion is wrong.
— Senator Rand Paul (@SenRandPaul) October 21, 2025
We shouldn’t do it off Venezuela either. These are small outboards with no fentanyl and no path to Florida.
We can’t just kill indiscriminately because we are not at war. It’s summary execution!… pic.twitter.com/CMb4m1aUF1
I like him most of the time, but I feel he's leaving out important context. Speed boats just off Miami are well within our 12 mile limit. Speedboats heading for open sea in international waters are a lot more suspicious than sailing craft generally operating in coastal waters. As for declared wars and Constitutional matters, I've mentioned before about Jefferson's undeclared actions against the Barbary States and Paul seems to be ignoring historical precedents such as that.
They're somewhat suspicious, so we murder them first and ask questions later (or maybe not at all?).
Taking action against pirates capturing and enslaving American crews is clearly a much different scenario than us blowing up civilian boats that pose no immediate, direct risk to America or Americans because *we think* they may be drug runners. Even if they're guilty of being drug runners, when did that become a capital offense? And most importantly, we don't even know they're drug runners unless we capture them and collect evidence!
Those clear differences aside, Jefferson eventually sought and got congressional approval and funding for his Barbary military actions.
When can we expect Trump to do the same for these military actions?
Jefferson only approached Congress at a certain threshold when he wanted to expand operations against the ruler of Tripoli. I don't know that the scale of current naval operations against these drug runners has come to that level yet.
I don't think that framing is right.
Tripoli declared war on the US, which was obviously begat a clear and immediate need to protect US interests. There was a hasty defensive deployment by the US in response.
Jefferson responded to the immediate threat and then doubled back to seek the congressional approval he thought the Constitution required.
There was no such attack on the US or its interests with the prospective drug runners. Who are we at war with? Who is attacking America? What's the difference between this and just beginning to drone strike people we see crossing the border that we believe may be drug mules?