Steve Videtich said:
Packchem91 said:
Steve Videtich said:
statefan91 said:
Steve Videtich said:
"Why not move a short distance away....where?"
Who said they have to move to low income housing? Are you saying they can't just choose to move to a better place with a better environment? And no I'm not saying it's as easy as flipping a light switch. But where there's a will there's a way.
"Why stay poor?"
You kind of answered your own statement here. Culture! That's the failing part of all of this. It takes a movement to change the culture, or remove yourself from the culture. For every example you give off things to overcome, you can find an example of somebody that has overcome those circumstances. It can happen, it's not impossible.
"legislators don't care about those in abject poverty"
Well, that's where I say to make change with you vote. They have that option as well. Nobody is forcing them to vote for crappy representation. I never said any of this is easy. But, there are thousands of examples that it's possible. I'm really not trying to argue about this, and I don't have all the answers. But if it's possible for some, it's possible for the many.
Do you feel like housing / rental prices are at a place where someone who is in a bad situation can easily move somewhere else? You say "where there's a will, there's a way" but what does that mean for people that have a will but no realistic way to get out of the cycle of poverty?
No, I don't. And again, I'm not saying that it's a decision that happens like turning on the lights. But, what you and Chem are doing is making excuses. Should those in poverty keep making excuses and just stay there. "My life sucks, I can't catch a break! I'm just going to get some weed and alcohol and hang with my friends and ***** about our lives." Is that a choice?
I'm really not trying to say this is easy, or that everybody can overcome these things that exist in poverty ridden areas. But, I do think the more people that do overcome, it could finish these areas over time. It's not an easy fix either. But, you have to start somewhere.
LOL, come on man, thats not making excuses, its reality. Tell you what, I don't know the worst, poorest school in your current district, but why don't you send your kids there for 12 years? Let them get the poorest resrouces and the poorest friends to hang out with for their developmental cycles?
Then lets test them when they graduate and see if they have the same principals and interests and motivations that the other kids in your current neighborhood.
I know what you're trying to say, and in theory I agree....ask my kids, I am 100% the "get up off the ground, shake it off, and get back at it" approach to life, and that has served them well.
But i think you underappreciate how stacked the deck is against many people to just say "suck it up".
Sooo....when you say you have to start somewhere -- do what? Cut them off and give them nothing, sink or swim?
If you're not married, we're going to take your kids? Sew you up so you can't have more?
You can LOL all you want. If people had your outlook, there wouldn't be any success stories in the game of life. Do you not know if anybody that overcame any of the things you mention as holding them back? I'll send my kids to whatever school you want me to. But, they'll still have me as a parent to kick their ass when they do something stupid and keep them in the right path.
I have a young man I worked with that was literally left in a garbage can, find and put through the foster system. He ended up going and playing college football, playing for Team USA football, and is an awesome motivational speaker. Did he have things stacked against him? Did he make a decision to get himself out of it?
Again, I'm not saying that everybody has the same wherewithal to do it. But, how many just give into the their surroundings and don't try? The more we help to turn the corner, I believe it becomes easier for the next one to do it. I'm also not talking about cutting anybody off. But, if people aren't willing to stand up for themselves and get helped, no matter what we do, they can't be helped.
What's the first step an alcoholic has to make?
Actually, if people had my outlook, and a supportive set of parents (though very blue collar, lower income), like I did, we'd be much better off, as my personal track record shows.
Nevertheless....if your kids did that, odds say they would not be as successful....but of course, having you there increases that odd very much. So of course with most poverty, that 2nd parent in the home does not exist.
So now who's teaching the accountability? If they don't learn it from 2 parents, where are they learning it? The street? The guy on the corner who is making $$$?
You point out an exception, and that is awesome. Something in his DNA, or somebody in his path that helped along the way I guess.
Look....I'd love for all these people impoverished to have some sort of great motivation to rise up. But I've been in a number of projects in Charlotte, and man, it is so depressing that it was easy to see how it is easy to take the wrong road....especially when daddy isn't there to kick the butt.