KenPom rankings since Keatts' first year: 46, 41, 50, 71, 129. That's the wrong direction. There are very obvious issues with KK's offensive and defensive schemes, and while he's faced a lot of misfortune, he hasn't given us a lot of reason to believe things will get better. At the same time, though, firing him risks losing Robert Dillingham, Terquavion Smith, maybe Judah Mintz... It's a pretty tough situation to navigate.
If Keatts really is done, the candidates that would get me the most excited are as follows:
Matt McMahon, Murray State: This is the guy we want, IMO.
- Currently has Murray State 26th in KenPom (their highest ranking ever) and 21st in the AP Poll
- 147-66 (.690 W-L%) overall; won three straight OVC regular season titles from 2018-2020 and two OVC tournament titles in that span
- Made it to the second round of the NCAA Tournament in 2019 with an upset over Marquette
- Played at Appalachian State and coached at both App State and UNC-W, so he has connections in North Carolina
- Coached Ja Morant, which is a HUGE selling point for recruits - especially a guard like Dilly - and also speaks to his ability to identify and develop talent (Ja was an unranked recruit and was drafted as the 2nd overall pick following his sophomore year; now a borderline superstar in the NBA)
- Just 43 years old
Bob Richey, Furman:
- Furman was never a top-100 KenPom team prior to Richey; they've been one every year since he's been head coach
- 106-44 (.707 W-L%) overall; set the Furman record with 25 wins in 2019 while getting them ranked for the first time ever (following a win over Villanova), and then matched that win total in 2020
- South Carolina guy, so semi-local, and has recruited some NC talent like Clay Mounce
- Just 38 years old
Kellen Sampson, Houston Assistant:
- His dad, Kelvin Sampson, is one of the best college coaches ever; he's been learning under him at Houston since 2014, and they've been one of the most successful programs in the country during that time period
- He was an assistant at App State, so he has connections in NC; he's helped recruit some high-level NC talent like Nate Hinton, Caleb Mills, and Rob Gray
- Just 36 years old
I would also expect us to look at guys like Mike Rhoades (VCU) and LeVelle Moton (NCCU). Also worth mentioning Grant McCasland (North Texas), who has been the best mid- to high-major candidate for a couple of seasons now IMO but is a Texas guy through and through so the fit is a little iffy.